Zootaxa: MS Evaluation Form
Reviewer A

Return to: add your address details
Author(s):
Title:

1. Are the data original and not yet published elsewhere?
2. Is the title appropriate and concise?
3. Is the abstract representative of the content?
4. Has the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature been correctly applied?
5. Are the interpretations justified?
6. Are the discussion and conclusions supported by the results?
7. Is the literature cited appropriate and comprehensive?
8. Are the tables and figures clear, all necessary, and well labeled?
9. Should some parts of the manuscript be modified, expanded, or omitted?
10. Is the structure of the manuscript optimal?
11. Is the total length of the manuscript in keeping with its content?

Reviewer’s comments (add more pages, if necessary):

Recommendation of the Reviewer A:

1. Acceptable as it is		2. Requires minor revision		3. Requires major revision
4. Unacceptable		5. Other recommendations

Reviewer, mark here if you wish to see the MS AFTER it is revised by the author:  

Thank you for reviewing this manuscript in a timely manner.
If you do not wish to remain anonymous, please sign here: